Unnamed Neutral Killing Role

TheUglyChickenCoo·9/12/2018 in Role Ideas (Neutral)

Name: Not known yet; one suggestion said Shadow. Attack: Unstoppable

Defense: Basic

Abilties:

Attack somebody once per night for an unstoppable attack. However, the second time somebody visits you while attacking somebody, you will deal a powerful attack to yourself.

If you choose to stay home, you will not be killed on visit.

Attributes: -n/a

Invest Results:

Sheriff: NS

Invest: Vigi, Vet, Mafioso, [Pirate], [Ambusher], [this role] These investigation results were chosen for a reason—the veteran. This role can function like an effective veteran, and there is no current Neutral role for classic mode in this invest result.

Reveal: [unsure yet] (i.e. Consigliere)

Goal: Kill all who would oppose you. (standard NK winning conditions)

(Edited by TheUglyChickenCoo)

Neutral Killing

Gob47·9/14/2018

TheRetroPioneer wrote:
Attack: Unstoppable oh boy (but balanced, I see)
Defense: Basic must have, or it's not Neutral Killing
Abilties:
Attack somebody once per night for an unstoppable attack. However, if somebody visits you while attacking somebody, you will deal a basic attack to yourself. even if it's investigative? or protective? like, i think it should just be an auto-vest like witch
If you choose to stay home, you will not be killed on visit. i see, this is interesting
Attributes:
You have temporary basic defense that disappears after one attack. You have a fierce reputation that disappears after an attack? idk

Invest Results:
Sheriff: NS nah Arso is special because it has detection immunity, add Your target is [Name]!
Invest: Vigi, Vet, Mafioso, [Pirate], [Ambusher], [this role] These investigation results were chosen for a reason—the veteran. This role can function like an effective veteran, and there is no current Neutral role for classic mode in this invest result. that's ok, but does he have a gun?
Reveal: [unsure yet]

Goal: Kill all who would oppose you. (standard NK winning conditions)

I think that this role needs to be more... complete. I do think, however, after it is, it seems mostly balanced.

(Edited by Gob47)

TheUglyChickenCoo·9/14/2018

In response to Gob47:

"that's ok, but does he have a gun?" No, because the Ambusher's art has a knife and no gun; also, it's really made for balancing reasons and not lore.

"i think it should just be an auto-vest like witch" to clarify, this is already put in

"I think that this role needs to be more... complete." I need some help there. Any other suggestions?

(Edited by TheUglyChickenCoo)

Gob47·9/14/2018

Name: Shadow

See Attribues/Sheriff (That's dumb, you probably did but yeah)

(Edited by Gob47)

TheMayor123·9/15/2018

Make it permanent basic defense, that should be the default for all neutral killing.

Make it so that the second time someone visit you will attacking, you deal a powerful attack to yourself.

(Edited by TheMayor123)

TheUglyChickenCoo·9/15/2018

TheMayor123 wrote:
Make it permanent basic defense, that should be the default for all neutral killing.
Make it so that the second time someone visit you will attacking, you deal a powerful attack to yourself.

Changed this to match your feedback.

(Edited by TheUglyChickenCoo)

TheMayor123·9/15/2018

thanks for taking my suggestions :)

(Edited by TheMayor123)

WellHidan·9/16/2018

TheRetroPioneer wrote:
Name: Not known yet; one suggestion said Shadow.
Attack: Unstoppable might wanna nerf this
Defense: Basic
Abilties:
Attack somebody once per night for an unstoppable attack. However, the second time somebody visits you while attacking somebody, you will deal a powerful attack to yourself. but why do you hit yourself.. just change the abiity to something that makes sense
If you choose to stay home, you will not be killed on visit.
Attributes:
You have temporary basic defense that disappears after one attack. why do you have basic defense in the first place?

Invest Results:
Sheriff: NS he kills people..
Invest: Vigi, Vet, Mafioso, [Pirate], [Ambusher], [this role] These investigation results were chosen for a reason—the veteran. This role can function like an effective veteran, and there is no current Neutral role for classic mode in this invest result.

Reveal: [unsure yet] wdym reveal?

Goal: Kill all who would oppose you. (standard NK winning conditions)

not bad for a role but makes no sense

(Edited by WellHidan)

TheUglyChickenCoo·9/16/2018

WellHidan wrote:

TheRetroPioneer wrote:
Name: Not known yet; one suggestion said Shadow.
Attack: Unstoppable might wanna nerf this I'm thinking about it; if there's something majorly wrong with this I'll change it to Powerful; you are right here
Defense: Basic
Abilties:
Attack somebody once per night for an unstoppable attack. However, the second time somebody visits you while attacking somebody, you will deal a powerful attack to yourself. but why do you hit yourself.. just change the abiity to something that makes sense I was going for balanced game mechanics; transporter making mafioso kill themself doens't make sense. (Unless you mean this is unbalanced)
If you choose to stay home, you will not be killed on visit.
Attributes:
You have temporary basic defense that disappears after one attack. why do you have basic defense in the first place? To survive one attack/one attacking mechanic; this has been changed to permanent defense now BTW thanks for noticing

Invest Results:
Sheriff: NS he kills people.. So does Godfather, Arsonist and Vigilante; they're counted as NS, so there's no theme to that.
Invest: Vigi, Vet, Mafioso, [Pirate], [Ambusher], [this role] These investigation results were chosen for a reason—the veteran. This role can function like an effective veteran, and there is no current Neutral role for classic mode in this invest result.

Reveal: [unsure yet] wdym reveal? I mean Consigliere

Goal: Kill all who would oppose you. (standard NK winning conditions)

not bad for a role but makes no sense

Helpful feedback. Updated a couple of things.

(Edited by TheUglyChickenCoo)

Heron the Mudkip·9/16/2018

The way this role works sounds like the way it kills might be bomb-related...

So maybe the name should be "Bomber"? Kind of a lame name, though

(Edited by Heron the Mudkip)

TheUglyChickenCoo·9/16/2018

Heron the Mudkip wrote:
The way this role works sounds like the way it kills might be bomb-related...
So maybe the name should be "Bomber"? Kind of a lame name, though

Not only that; it doesn't really follow the theme of Town of Salem. Maybe something related to that, maybe.

(Edited by TheUglyChickenCoo)

What do you think?